Decision-to-Value™ Method  /  Case library
Case library

Fourteen decisions, read through five steps

Public cases from nine countries, dated November 2023 or later. Each one shows the decision, which steps of the method it exercised and what the numbers say. The failures are documented by an auditor, a regulator or a filing.

Banco Santander logoBanco SantanderSpain · Banking · Listed (BME/NYSE)Success
Anchor Case · Success

The decision

Stop running as a group of local banks and move to shared global platforms, against a public efficiency target.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
A unit metric, cost per active customer, ties strategy to the management committee.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • Cost-to-income ratio fell to 41.2% under ONE Transformation, from 45.8% three years earlier (FY2025, reported Feb 2026).
  • Cost per active customer down 4% (FY2025).
  • Gravity, the cloud core banking platform, live in Spain and Mexico (Feb 2026).

Sources: Santander, Results 2025 (Feb 2026) · SEC Form 6-K, FY2025 results · SEC Form 6-K, H1 2025

NHSNHS EnglandUnited Kingdom · Healthcare · GovernmentMixed
Anchor Case · Mixed

The decision

Replace the national cost collection with each hospital's own cost model, rolled out in waves.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
The clearest example of what it costs not to have reconciled data on time.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • 2026/27 national prices are still set with 2018/19 costing data (consultation, Nov 2025 – Mar 2026).
  • The 2023/24 national cost collection did not arrive in time to be used.
  • Local Cost Collection: first 15 West Yorkshire providers, then up to 50 trusts.

Sources: NHS England, 2026/27 NHSPS consultation proposals · HFMA, Local Cost Collection · HFMA, Pay more attention to costing data

UPS logoUPSUnited States · Logistics · Listed (NYSE)Success
Anchor Case · Success

The decision

Exit low-margin volume and grow in small and mid-sized business, B2B and healthcare, with a smaller, more automated network.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data weak
  5. 5 Lead the change
Customer profitability changed which volume UPS keeps.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • Amazon was 11.8% of revenue: “our largest customer but not our most profitable” (Jan 2025).
  • UPS cut that volume by more than half and reported US$3.5 billion in savings in 2025.
  • Caution: about 48,000 operational positions were cut, so the case carries a social cost.

Sources: FreightWaves (30 Jan 2025) · UPS Annual Report FY2025 (SEC)

DBS Group logoDBS GroupSingapore · Banking · Listed (SGX)Success
Banking & Insurance · Success

The decision

Manage AI as a portfolio of use cases, each with its value measured against a control group.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
Measure the value of a decision with a control group.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • S$750 million of economic value from data and AI in 2024, more than double 2023 (Mar 2025).
  • Measured with test and control groups across 370+ use cases and 1,500+ models.
  • Caution: the figure is not audited, and its definition has changed since 2022.

Sources: DBS Annual Report 2024, CIO statement · Terence Kok (secondary)

Tryg logoTrygDenmark (also Norway and Sweden) · Insurance · Listed (Nasdaq Copenhagen)Success
Banking & Insurance · Success

The decision

Reprice by line and country, and cut exposure to the Corporate segment.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
A public KPI disciplines cost and price at the same time.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • 2024 expense ratio of 13.5% and combined ratio of 81.0%; all targets met (Jan 2025).
  • Motor prices in Norway raised by about 13% (2024).
  • DKK 930 million of synergies to date from the RSA Scandinavia integration (2024).

Sources: Tryg Annual report 2024 (Jan 2025) · Q3 2024 earnings call · Q2 2024 earnings call

Handelsbanken logoHandelsbankenSweden (also UK, Norway, Netherlands) · Banking · Listed (Nasdaq Stockholm)Success
Banking & Insurance · Success

The decision

Sell the Finnish operation to S-Bank and concentrate on the markets with the highest long-term profitability.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business weak
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
Comparing efficiency by market leads to deciding where to compete.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • Cost-to-income ratio by market, 2024: Sweden 29.9%, United Kingdom 52.5%.
  • Same ratio in 2025: Sweden 31.7%, United Kingdom 57.5%.
  • Exit from Finland completed in 2024.

Sources: Annual Report 2024 highlights · Annual Report 2025 highlights · Resolution plan to the Federal Reserve, Jul 2025

Cemex logoCemexMexico · Manufacturing (cement) · Listed (BMV/NYSE)Success
Industry · Success

The decision

Rebalance the asset portfolio by value created against the cost of capital, and widen the efficiency program.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
Return per asset against the cost of capital decides what stays and what is sold.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • Since 2025, value creation is measured per asset against the cost of capital (Feb–Apr 2026).
  • Sold its operations in the Dominican Republic (Jan 2025) and Panama (Oct 2025).
  • Project Cutting Edge: US$200 million of savings in 2025; target of US$400 million by 2027.

Sources: Cemex 2025 Integrated Report · Cemex 20-F 2025 · 2024 results (SEC)

FEMSA logoFEMSAMexico · Retail and consumer · Listed (BMV/NYSE)In progress
Consumer · In progress

The decision

Exit the non-core businesses and focus on retail, Coca-Cola FEMSA and digital.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
Before you model, define which business you are.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • FEMSA Forward, announced 15 Feb 2023, focuses the group on retail, Coca-Cola FEMSA and digital.
  • Sold its refrigeration business (Nov 2024) and its plastic solutions business (Jan 2025).
  • Redefined the role of the corporate center.

Sources: FEMSA 20-F 2024 · SEC Form 6-K, 23 Feb 2024

Hitachi logoHitachiJapan · Manufacturing and technology · Listed (TSE)Success
Industry · Success

The decision

Deconsolidate Astemo and restructure the home appliance and ATM businesses against a published ROIC hurdle.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
A published hurdle rate makes portfolio decisions open to review.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • The Inspire 2027 plan sets an ROIC hurdle rate of 12–13% (Jun 2025).
  • Reported ROIC of 12.4% for fiscal 2025.
  • Businesses that do not clear the hurdle are divested (Investor Day, Jun 2026).

Sources: Integrated Report 2025, CFO message · Integrated Report 2026 · Investor Day 2026, CFO

Mayo Clinic logoMayo ClinicUnited States · Healthcare · Non-profitSuccess
Healthcare · Success

The decision

Use a time-driven activity-based costing study to back the extension of early mobilization after stroke.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
One unit cost, told as one number, changes a clinical decision.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • TDABC study of 180 stroke patients: US$3,750 per patient with early mobilization vs US$5,000 (Feb 2026).
  • Savings of 25%: US$225,000 in total and 90 bed-days.
  • Caution: savings are modelled and come from a single center; Robert S. Kaplan is a co-author.

Sources: Ghosh et al., Mayo Clin Proc Innov Qual Outcomes, 23 Feb 2026

BCCBirmingham City CouncilUnited Kingdom · Local government · Public sectorDocumented failure
Documented failure

The decision

Re-implement Oracle Fusion from scratch, with no customizations.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
Without understanding the business, the system has no one to serve.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • Estimated at £19 million plus £1 million contingency; projected cost of £144.4 million to 2027/28.
  • Bank reconciliation failed, and the council cannot produce auditable accounts (Jan 2026).
  • Grant Thornton: leaders did not understand what they bought (Feb 2025). Context: 2023 bankruptcy notice.

Sources: The Register, 25 Feb 2025 · The Register, 29 Jan 2026 · Computing, Feb 2025

Zimmer Biomet logoZimmer BiometUnited States · Medical devices · Listed (NYSE)Documented failure
Documented failure

The decision

Remediate the new ERP across U.S. and Canada sales and commercial operations, and sue the implementer to recover the cost.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
If the data does not flow on day one, the business stops on day one.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • New ERP went live in July 2024 for a significant portion of U.S. and Canada sales and commercial operations (Form 10-Q, Q3 2024).
  • Shipping problems were expected to cut about 1% of 2024 revenue, more than half of it in Q3 (investor conference, Sep 2024).
  • Caution: in Sep 2025 the company sued Deloitte for US$172 million; Deloitte disputes the claims and asked the court to dismiss the suit (Nov 2025).

Sources: SEC Form 10-Q, Q3 2024 · Investing.com, 17 Sep 2024 · MassDevice, 8 Sep 2025 · MassDevice, 10 Nov 2025

Lamb Weston logoLamb WestonUnited States · Manufacturing (food) · Listed (NYSE)Documented failure
Documented failure

The decision

Send staff to the distribution centers and change the approach for the next ERP waves.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
Data you cannot see is a sale you do not make.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • The ERP transition removed visibility of finished-goods inventory (Q3 FY2024).
  • About US$135 million of lost sales and US$72 million of net income in that quarter.
  • Caution: securities class action in Idaho (case 24-cv-282), motion to dismiss pending.

Sources: SEC Form 8-K, Q3 FY2024 · SEC Form 10-K FY2024 · Supply Chain Dive

GCGovernment of CanadaCanada · Public sector (payroll) · GovernmentDocumented failure
Documented failure

The decision

Replace the Phoenix pay system with Dayforce, under stronger governance.

D2V steps

  1. 1 Understand the business
  2. 2 Communicate with impact
  3. 3 Model the business
  4. 4 Prepare relevant data
  5. 5 Lead the change
If you do not simplify the rules, the new system inherits the problem.Author's interpretation

What the numbers show

  • Phoenix cost more than C$5.1 billion through June 2025.
  • Its replacement is estimated at more than C$4.2 billion.
  • Auditor General: Dayforce is being customized instead of simplifying pay rules; 233,653 transactions backlogged (Mar 2026).

Sources: CBC, Mar 2026 · Global News, Mar 2026

Select a case to open it. Figures are copied from the sources listed with each case; the line in the box is the author's reading of what the method takes from it.

Company names, logos and trademarks belong to their owners. They are used here only to identify the organizations discussed and do not imply any affiliation with, or endorsement by, them or of the book Decision-to-Value™ Method.